The Carson Wentz experiment in Indianapolis is a failure
Why did anyone think Carson Wentz would work at Indy?
I understand that a change of scenery can do a lot of people good, but I never thought it could possibly turn the worst quarterback of 2020 into one who could claim a Super Bowl. It’s crazy to me that so many domestic media place such high expectations on Wentz just because he was traded, especially when he was traded only because of his bad play.
“He has talent around him. There is a good football team in Indy, ”said Dan Orlovsky, someone who is probably lying in bed staring at a Carson Wentz Fathead on the ceiling. “This is an 11-5 football team from last year that is pretty much the same returning team – the same returning team, but more talented… Carson Wentz is expected to win the division and wins a playoff game. “
“The norm is 2017, not 2019… and I think he can be successful,” said Stephen A. Smith.
“I am not a fan of Wentz, but if he can relaunch his career anywhere, it is with this coach who was obviously his coordinator in Philadelphia, behind this offensive line, which could well be the best in football. , and this racing game that comes from is up there at the top of the league. So when you have those components, you have a chance, ”Skip Bayless said.
Aaaa and 0-3. AKA Jets-Giants-Lions territory. The Colts could still turn things around, but at 0-3 you can pretty much count the playoffs, which is one of the minimum requirements to win a playoff game, as Orlovsky thought.
This quote from Skip Bayless is some of the sweetest support for Wentz – basically he just says he’s going for a good team – but it points to a lot of reasons people were saying Wentz would jumpstart his career. The problem is, Quentin Nelson can only protect the quarterback, he can’t make the shots for him.
Let’s try a critical thinking exercise, what I realize is a super pretentious thing to say, but bear with me. We have two quarterbacks: QB A and QB B. QB A is bad, but took a starting position away from QB B. It stands to reason that QB B is also bad, right? Even worse than QB A.
Prepare to get drunk. QB A is Jalen Hurts and QB B is Carson Wentz. This is the main reason why I never understood the Wentz hype. Often the same people who said Wentz would be an MVP candidate were the ones who said Jalen Hurts’ days were numbered in Philadelphia. But Wentz was so bad he was benched for Hurts! I feel like I’m screaming into the void here. Maybe I’m the fool.
This critical thinking exercise was aimed primarily at Dan Orlovsky, who said this on Pat McAfee’s show: “They are not close as players. Carson Wentz is superior as a player.
I repeat: Wentz was benched for Hurts! You worship a false prophet, Daniel!
But it all comes down to “the list”. Indy’s is much better than Philly’s and that will make all the difference, right? Last year Wentz had a QBR of 41.9, good for the 28th among qualifiers. This year, with the O line, running game, receivers and the former coordinator, he improved to 38.9.
It follows, because it just isn’t that good. It also indicates that he is behind Jalen Hurts’ 41.2 QBR this year, because for the last time Hurts took his job.
I don’t want to hate Wentz. He’s actually a Super Bowl-winning quarterback, even though he didn’t play in the game. He was on the list and played a big part in getting them there. It’s just ridiculous to keep acting like he’s still this guy when all the evidence proves otherwise.